Why promote science fairs

This week the LA Convention Center was filled with poster boards and precocious students for the Intel International Science and Engineering Fair. The biggest science fair in the world attracts more than 1,500 participants from 65 countries. This year’s $75,000 grand prize went to Matthew Fedderson and Blake Marggraff of Lafayette, California for their research on treating simulated cancer cells with Compton-scattered secondary radiation. Nothing less than professional-level science projects (albeit with the help of a scientist mentor in most cases) can be expected from ISEF.

I participated in the fair for a day as a volunteer interpreter and was able to meet some of the Japanese students. They qualified by winning national-level high school science fairs in Japan – impressive students on paper and in person.

In science fairs the first hurdle is to come up with a good question. You can’t just ask a big question like, “How can I cure cancer?” The best questions come from a simple observation in your surroundings. The next hurdle is to design a clean, simple experiment to test your hypothesis.

I helped out with a student who experimented with liquid nitrogen. While playing with liquid nitrogen he noticed that some materials boil within the nitrogen, calm down, and then re-boil. He asked, “Why does re-boiling occur?” He observed a simple mechanism and being curious, wondered how it works. After testing re-boiling for many materials he found that re-boiling occurred the most for materials with high thermal conductivity.

With the help of a high-speed camera he also discovered that a film of bubbles collects on the material before it re-boils. He then tested whether the film of bubbles causes re-boiling by breaking the film with a heating wire. That’s the part of the experiment that I really like – he found a way to disrupt the film of bubbles and observe what happens in its absence. It’s a well-designed experiment. He found that when he applied more current to the heating wire, the material finished reboiling faster. The conclusion: cooling can be accelerated if the film of bubbles is broken by non-uniform heating.

The schedule for the students is pretty grueling. They are at the convention center from 7am to 6pm, where they present their experiment to judges in English, a second language for them. One of the people from the Japanese team remarked that these students can present their science projects better in English than they can do small talk in English. Ask them how surface area affects reboiling in liquid nitrogen and they’ll answer straight away. But as a judge if you try to break the ice with, “Have you visited Disneyland yet?” they get a little thrown off.

I was very happy to meet these students. They were mature and at the top of their game. One of them gave me a Japanese fan, too! There was a clip from NPR that pointed out that kids (especially those at this science fair) can contribute to science and offer something different. Where an older, trained scientist may think that something will never work, a kid might look at something in a new way. She might ask, “Why not?”